,
This is a placeholder for the Yext Knolwedge Tags. This message will not appear on the live site, but only within the editor. The Yext Knowledge Tags are successfully installed and will be added to the website.
Paul Michael Brick Oven Cafe Restaurant logo
This is a placeholder for the Yext Knolwedge Tags. This message will not appear on the live site, but only within the editor. The Yext Knowledge Tags are successfully installed and will be added to the website.

Specialty Pizzas

Specialty Pizza Services

Made Fresh Daily | Family Recipes | Local Ingredients

Made Fresh Daily

Family Recipes

Local Ingredients

Visit Us

Hours:

This is a placeholder for the Yext Knolwedge Tags. This message will not appear on the live site, but only within the editor. The Yext Knowledge Tags are successfully installed and will be added to the website.

Pizza Is What We Do Best

We do pizza the right way. We use the freshest and finest ingredients to add a taste that stands apart from the standard pizza shop.


We know that better ingredients really do make for better pizza. From all your standard toppings to selections that are more unique, you'll find many mouthwatering choices when you visit Paul Michael's Brick Oven Cafe Restaurant.


Our brick ovens cook your pizza at the perfect temperature, guaranteeing the very best crispiness and enjoyment in each bite. Come in and try our specialty pizzas. We challenge you to find your favorite.

Some Unique Favorites

  • Mezza Luna - Chicken, tomatoes, and onions topped with mozzarella cheese
  • Chicken Cacciatore - Chicken, sauteed onions, mushrooms, and tomato sauce
  • Buffalo Wing - Spicy chicken topped with blue cheese
  • Baked Ziti - Penne pasta, ricotta, marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese

Our Newest Additions

  • Eggplant Rolatini - Eggplant, ricotta, tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese
  • San Gennaro - Sausage, onion, peppers, mozzarella cheese
  • House Special - Meatballs, pepperoni, sausage, onions, peppers, and mushrooms

Enjoy a Pan Pizza

  • Sicilian - Thick-crusted pan pizza with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese
  • Grandma - Thin-crust pan pizza with mozzarella on bottom w/ fresh basil garlic sauce on top
  • Caprese - Grandma crust topped with fresh mozzarella, basil, sliced tomatoes, and roasted peppers

Available All Day

Get pizza for lunch or dinner

Visit Us
hibu-tm

I always say, if you want good pizza in NYC, forget Manhattan and come to the outer boroughs. Paul Michael's is my favorite pizza place in my hood.

- Christine M.

Learn More About

Paul Michael's Brick Oven Cafe Restaurant

Play Video
Share by: